American Idol Report Card - The Top 10 Girls
Oof, where do I begin? I don’t think that my pal Kool and his gang would have found last night’s ladies night feeling right. It verged on suckdom for me - especially when compared to Tuesday night’s performances from the guys.
The show started out with a bang, but soon dropped like a two-ton, heavy thing. From the top:
Carly “Pub Girl” Smithson - Carly works in an Irish bar and owns a tattoo shop, but loves to clean and cook - now Paula, here is a girl for you with many “colors” in her rainbow. Taking a tip from the Michael Johns’ school of song selection, Carly chose a song she loves and always wanted to sing on AI - thankfully, it was a good one. She had the best vocal of the night by far, and she looked great. I think she wore those boots last week, but they made much more of a statement with this week’s outfit. Overall great performance, but she needs to stop dancing like Michael Johns, because when wearing low cut tops the girlie parts tend to start jigglin’ and it can be quite distracting.
Syesha “DeWayne is My Manservant” Mercado - Watching an adult woman smile almost sadisticly while mimicking the sound of a very unhappy infant is just the creepiest thing this side of Neverland Ranch, thankyouverymuch. I much prefer the Britney impressions from Kady Malloy. Syesha, well - I am liking her less and less. She lost her pitch on all the low notes, and I am of the belief that unless she’s shouting it, she ain’t hittin’ it. The peformance was trying to be sultry and sweet, but was more nightclub-ish karaoke and forgettable. And enough with the hula hoop earrings people!
Brooke “Beauty School Dropout” White - A ridiculously safe choice of song, but it suited her and will definitely keep her in the running for the top 10. Her vocal didn’t showcase a high degree of difficulty, but it played to her strengths and the guitar definitely kept her shiny happy dance moves in check. Her top and boots were tres chic, and it is good to see that ol’ Simey can still bring out the sass in such a syrupy sweet girl.
Ramiele “Don’t Call Me Lullaby” Malubay - The judges weren’t too impressed by “Rami” last night, and while I agree that she is definitely capable of better, she wasn’t awful - the arrangement of the song was, however. The flow of the chorus was totally off, and just didn’t make me feel like dancin’. The outfit was all wrong for this type of song, as well. She shoulda glammed it up a bit. If she doesn’t do something to step up her stage presence, she could go the way of Season 5’s early eliminated P.Y.T. (Petite Young Thing) - Lisa Tucker. Besides, I think these super skinny jeans she keeps wearing put her at serious risk of Camelus Toeitis.
Kristy Lee “The Decontaminated” Cook - I guess taking 5 different antibiotics makes your performance more RObotic - at least that is how Kristy justified last week’s flu-induced freakshow. Kristy does have a voice with a lot of potential, if she could pull herself away from the LAME song choices. It was good to see that she shunned the Shania stage moves and facial expressions, and found herself a pseudo-rock stance instead. Girlfriend’s performance was most improved of the week (except for maybe Carly), and she has already earned more rock cred in one show than Robbie has all season.
Amanda “Brace Yourselves!” Overmyer - Oh Ryan, thanks for the warning. We had no idea what was coming our way, we should have taken heed of your warning. This was a performance for the American Idol history books, for sho. Cruella Joplin was apparently in the mood for a melody, but melody apparently wanted no part of Amanda. She busted some high energy moves, but how will my bleeding ears ever recover enough to enjoy “Carry On Wayward Son” while playing Guitar Hero III ever again? Assuming she goes home this week, hopefully she will leave some of her hair volumizing product with fellow rocker David Cook.
Alaina “Foodie Phobe” Whitaker - Predictable, pitchy and pageanty. And that is all I have to say about that.
Alexandrea “Random” Lushington - I know I am an old fart, but I didn’t get Alex’s look last night - especially when you pair it with a moody, mellow Chicago song. It seemed very random, almost as if “the package” was wrapped up in (or maybe something changed) the very last minute. Speaking of random - am I the only one that thinks she sounds like she skips around in different keys within a song? It’s so trippy how she do. I would like to see her back for another week - not so much based on her talent, but that I kinda like her. Most of the girls could learn a lesson in humility from her.
Kady ”It’s Kay-tee!” Malloy - Better start praying for Opera theme week (if you see another week), young Kady - for your hopes for pop stardom of a Britney magnitude in are dwindling fast. Mr. Jovi claimed that this performance put his feet to sleep - if only it had put my ears to sleep, as well. The girl has talent up the wazoo (and probably other places, as well), but she has no idea where or how to showcase it. She seems really immature, and I suspect this is her roadblock right now.
Asia’h “The H Whisperer” Epperson - Uh, the hair extensions really weren’t working for me for her. She kept stroking them as she sang, and I kept waiting for her to start sucking on it or chewing it like the girls with really long hair back in elementary school. *SHUDDER* She stood out before with her shorter, spunkier hairstyle, so I hope she reconsiders the new ‘do. I don’t think her vocal was bad, in spite of the incredible disappearing note early in the song. That being said, she just isn’t a Whitney, Celine or Mariah type of singer, and should stay far away from any song these chicks ever sang or thought about sangin’. Some risks just aren’t worth splittin’ seams on your dress while trying to hit a note.
My predictions on who will go home tonight - while typically not very accurate - are mathematically calculated by a very respected consensus of scientists, so don’t be hatin’:
Baby Come Back: David Archuleta, Michael Johns, Jason Castro, David Hernandez, Carly Smithson, Brooke White and Ramiele Malubay
We’ve Only Just Begun: Danny Noriega, Chikezie, David Cook, Kristy Lee Cook, Alaina Whitaker, Alexandrea Lushington and Asia’h Epperson
Don’t Give Up On Us, Baby: Luke Menard, Robbie Carrico, Jason Yeager, Syesha Mercado, Amanda Overmyer and Kady Malloy
Dust In The Wind: Robbie Carrico, Jason Yeager, Amanda Overmyer and Kady Malloy
See you in the emergency room!
This entry was posted on Thursday, February 28th, 2008 at 7:46 pm and is filed under Television, American Idol.











