The Top 24 have been decided, kiddies!
It seems like it took us so very long to arrive at our American Idol Top 24 - and yet, I hardly know anything about (let alone heard a single note sung by):
Jason “Judge Dredlock” Castro
“Leif” Garrett Haley
Luke “Legolas” Menard
Jason “Live From Branson” Yeager
The contestants above receive a grade of Incomplete on their Idol report card due to simple lack of exposure. I wish the Idol Powers That Be would rethink this policy for next season. I don’t think it is asking too much to see the Top 24 contestants at least once prior to Hollywood week. It’s not like there isn’t time in the schedule, folks! Was it more important that we view the inevitable crash and burn of Amy Catherine Flynn? Not to say I didn’t delight in it, but I would rather they give me the good stuff.
Maybe I just need some justification that young Josiah Leming deserves to return to living life in his car. I will concede that “Stand By Me” was a train wreck - but maybe only because we could not hear the music in his head? You gotta admit that his version of “Grace Kelly” was damn cool - especially when compared to the countless tired versions of “Ribbon In The Sky” we are subjected to year after year. The cool factor is practically non-existent this early in the competition. Josiah at least made it interesting.
So, the 24 that remain make up what is probably the most diverse Idol group we have seen in a while. It should be a fun ride as we see who rises to the top - and I definitely already have my favorites. I have graded them below - on a curve, of course - because really, they are all winners at this point. Right Paula?
DECIDEDLY HOT:
Michael Johns - A+
Mama likes what she sees so far, laddie. I am not sure why David Cook continues to be referred to as the resident rocker this season. Homeboy doesn’t hold a gothic pewter candlestick to Michael. Rock and roll fans, this is the contestant I am looking towards to further our cause! I am guessing that Michael’s version of “Bohemian Rhapsody” made King Freddie smile and quiver with delight upon his throne in Rock N’ Roll Heaven. Dee-lish!
David Archuleta - A
I believe David earned the first patented Randy-ism (”That was da bomb!”) of the season. Well deserved. His “Heaven” audition was good enough to inspire me to dust off my Bryan Adams “Reckless” LP and sing into my hairbrush. David just gives me the warm fuzzies - his innocence and humility have charmed this jaded ol’ heart o’ mine.
Asia’h Epperson - A-
Asia’h has improved dramatically for me since her original audition. She seems to have better control of her breathing when she sings, and I think she definitely looks the part of the American Idol. She is adorable times a tradillion percent… Or was it trazillion?
Chikezie Eze - A-
We didn’t get to see any of his Hollywood week auditions, but for some reason we did see some of his reaction shots to what I can only assume were the judges comments. He looked happy, and I sense there are good things in store from Chikezie and his yummy voice - plus, he was one of my favorite auditions of the season.
Carly Smithson - B+
I guess a “doost” mask is the cure for what ails ya when you are allergic to your doggie. Don’t you just love Irish accents? Maybe it’s just me, as I am a card carrying Bono worshipper. Carly didn’t overwhelm me with her original audition, and I admit I am still a little on the fence - the producers seem to be force-feeding her to us. I will cut her some slack, as she does seem like a cool chickie, and in spite of the Cher-meets-Celine quality of her voice, I think she is talented. I just hope her boyfriend will quit inking up her lovely Irish skin - it’s gettin’ to be a little much for hi-def TV.
Ramiele Malubay - B+
I am warming to Ramiele. She still comes off as a little phoney and that annoys me a teeny bit, but her voice really is outstanding. It won’t be easy to outsing her - but probably not too a huge feat to be more likeable/memorable.
DECIDEDLY UNDECIDED:
Danny Noriega - B
Has anyone else noticed that Danny, Ramiele and Colton all have a version of Clay Bangs? Did someone call for a makeover? Okay, back to Danni “Boy” - I love his energy, and his voice is WOW. I do think that the silly “sistah diva” performance moves will become annoying sooner than later. Hopefully he can tone it down and just SING - he will do better if he works on selling his voice, not himself.
Brooke White - B
Brooke has a very funky, indie vibe about her, and I like it. She might be too pure and vulnerable to take a real risk, which could hurt her when the competition really digs in.
Kady Malloy - B
Judging from her original audition, she should be able to show a lot of versatility come theme weeks. Plus, pretty blondes seem to stick around whether they are worthy or not. Could suffer as a result of being interchangable with Alaina Whitaker.
Amanda Overmyer - B-
I really like Amanda’s look and personality. She has a growl to be reckoned with, though sometimes it verges on phlegmy, rather than raspy. If I am being honest, I do not agree with Randy that she will revive the 60’s sound. I don’t know anyone that is saving their tie dye shirts and burning their bras in the hopes of that happening - do you? To stand a chance, Amanda is going to have to TKO a post-1970’s rock song, while making it her own. I fear anything she sings will sound like Janis karaoke.
Syesha Mercado - B-
I didn’t care for Syesha’s orignal audition in Miami, but she worked it out in her “Chain of Fools” audition, dawg. The pitchiness of her original audition seems to have been eliminated, but she still oversings and makes my ears bleed a little (gee, I wonder where her voice went?) I do hope that if she loses her voice again, that she will leave the annoying INXS “Mediate” signage at home.
Robbie Carrico - B-
I am not feeling the whole Bret Michaels makeover, and I am a little skeptical on just how an ex boy band-er evolves into a rocker - but I must give him the benefit of the doubt for now, as there is a pretty darn good voice lurking under that doo-rag. Hopefully the Idol stylists will execute a look that doesn’t completely clash with the boy-band goodness of his voice, and showcases his inner Jon Bon Timberlake.
David Hernandez - C+
I can’t put my finger on it, but David is a little annoying for me when he performs. His vocal range is delicious, and he is a really good looking guy. It just seems like he takes himself too seriously, performs kind of in a poser-y manner, and lacks charisma. He needs to make his mark early - or he will be going the way of pack-it-in-Patrick Hall.
Kristy Lee Cook - C+
Anyone else see this horse lover as a one-trick pony? Enough with the “Amazing Grace” redux - sooner or later the object of my brother’s affection will have to step out of her comfy zone, and I have to wonder if she will be as worthy as she has been built up to be? Of course, Kimberley Locke drowned us in version after version of “Over The Rainbow” in the early rounds of Season 2, and she faired pretty well.
DECIDEDLY NOT:
David Cook - C
Dave seems like a nice enough guy, but nothing about him screams ROCK DUDE!! to me. Maybe it was his pasty white head, blue tongue and Easter egg colored hair. I find him forgetable. Meh.
Alaina Whitaker - C-
I remember her as being ‘too big for her britches’ in her original audition, and she will suffer from being interchangable with the more talented Kady Malloy.
Joanne Borgella - C-
She is stunning, and her personality is fantastic - I just cannot warm to the voice. A little too Stevie Scott for me.
Colton Berry - D+
Casper, or Whitey (as I like to call him) definitely has his work cut out for him. What little sampling of his voice I heard sent me right to sleepy-sleep. On the surface, it seems that Colton is kind of a nervous guy. The only thing that will save him is if it rains wine and roses as he sings…
Alexandrea Lushington - D
It is probably not fair of me to grade her this way - maybe a grade of Incomplete would be more appropriate. I only heard a couple seconds of her audition, and it didn’t thrill me. She will have to work harder than any other girl in the competition to get noticed.
Amy Davis - F
I am guessing she must have brought her “large repitoire” to Hollywood, because I just don’t understand this choice by the judges. Her original audition of “Blue Bayou” was cookie-cutter and weak. Too bad that is all we have seen so far.
Suggestions to improve Hollywood week for next season - can we please eliminate:
- Flirty promotional fantasies between Ryan and other sexually ambiguous celebrities
- Paula’s Rambling Chamber of Torture (I think her schoolmarm bun inspired this blog)
- Simon’s hissy fits when he doesn’t agree with a decision
- Shots of Randy from the waist down - were those shoes a gift from Cousin Eddie?
- The 10K walk to the judges table, unless it’s for charity
- Instruments - drums, in particular - unless Phil Collins auditions
Good riddance to:
Amy Catherine Flynn - Try to abstain from songs you learned yesterday!
Brooke Helvie - Back to the pageant circuit you go - pay attention in manners class!
“Garlic” Ghaleb Emachah and Cardin McKinney - Get a frikkin’ room!
Sorry to see you go:
Josiah Leming - Learn not to fall in love with your own ideas. You are wee, but with experience, you’ll learn. You have got it, so use it!
Leo Marlowe - I feel like I have been jilted at the Homecoming dance. 
Kyle Ensley - You have been disenfranchised. I’d vote for you.
Angela Martin - God bless you and Jessie. You are a class act.
Ronald Hodge - How do you keep going now? (Ryan’s insensitive question of the year!)
Class dismissed!
This entry was posted on Monday, February 18th, 2008 at 7:08 pm and is filed under Television, American Idol.